WILLIS HALL HERALD ONLINE
  • Home
  • News
    • Head of School Armistead Lemon
  • Sports 2022-23
  • Features
    • Profiles >
      • Student Profiles
      • New Teacher Profiles
      • Leadership Profiles
      • Seniors: Class of 2021
      • Seniors: Class of 2022
  • GEOPRISM
  • Opinion
  • Arts
    • Scary Stories
    • April Fools Day
  • Print Issues
  • Photos
    • Homecoming
  • Ads
  • Staff
    • Aadeetri Pandey '26
    • Anne Bradley Cullen '26
    • Antonio Mack '26
    • Brock Miles '24
    • Dat Bui '23
    • Didi Dibetle '24
    • Eason Zhou '24
    • Gracean Ratliff '23
    • Hania Raza '24
    • Helen Hertz '24
    • Jiale Qin '26
    • Kenzie Raub '24
    • Lam Do '26
    • Massoki Maka '23
    • Nhi Le '25
    • Rabia Ferron '26
    • Rowan Anderson '26
    • Tristan Lange '26
    • Veronica Weston '26
    • Robert Robillard
  • Resources
  • News Archive
    • Coronavirus
    • Student Profiles
    • Teacher Profiles
    • Sports 2021-22 >
      • Football: State Champs

News

Dr. Proctor discusses retirement with Herald staff

Cheating on the physics exam draws attention to honor

12/17/2014

1 Comment

 
By Tanner Smith
   I will not lie, I will not cheat, I will not steal.
   These three short phrases compose the Honor Code of North Cross School. They are 12 simple words loaded with huge meaning. There was a breach in the code during the ninth grade physics exam. While taking the exam, which was on the iPad, nine students accessed notes or websites to help them on the test. While the intention for them was to boost their grade, their grades instead went in the opposite direction once their actions were discovered. Not only did they each receive a zero for their exams, they also incurred the judgment of 11 of their peers on the Honor Council. Jennifer Landry, Honor Council chair, thinks that some students have a limited understanding of the code, especially as it applies to iPads.
   “I think there is a problem with how students don’t understand how it can be different when they are taking a test on the iPad,” she said. “I asked a student if they thought it was okay if they were taking a test on paper to then go and look up the stuff on the iPad or on a computer, they looked at me like I was crazy. I think they see an iPad in front of them and assume they have access to the Internet.”
   Daniel Habib (’18) thinks that while the students were wrong to cheat, the physics test was set up to fail.
   “I think that there were more opportunities for someone to cheat than should have been allowed,” he said.
   Headmaster Dr. Christian J. Proctor is a huge proponent of trusting students to follow the Honor Code. In fact, he thinks that the school should get to the point where students don’t need any supervision for exams.
   “We should be able to send the exams home with students,” he said “and have them take the exams on their own time like Washington & Lee students do for their exams.”
   Meghan McDonnell (’15), who is a member of the Honor Council, has internal motivation to be honorable along with the school’s Honor Code.
   “I want to get into college and I want to do that myself,” she said. “I don’t want any other outside factors; it has to be me.”
   The school hopes to groom other students with this mentality, which is the purpose of the Honor Council. Landry tries to let the students dominate the conversations.
   “In my role, I try to speak as little as possible,” she said. “I am really only there to take notes and to run the meeting. The faculty here does meet after school if there has been an honor offense, but they are not allowed to change the decision of the Honor Council in determining whether an honor offense has occurred.”
   While the students determine whether an honor offense has occurred, Proctor has the final say on punishment. Proctor takes a number of factors into consideration when making a decision, but his core belief is very simple.
   “If you cheat, you cheat,” he said. “It doesn’t matter whether you are copying a homework assignment or cheating on a major exam. The punishment can be different, but to me I am not punishing one more lightly than the other, I am punishing the situation differently.
   “They are both still cheating, but I will vary the punishment both by situation, age and if you had done it before. If you had done it once before and now you are a second time loser it is a very serious punishment at that point because you didn’t learn the first time. In life sometimes you make a mistake but once you start making several mistakes then the punishment can get bad in a hurry.”
   McDonnell agrees that a variety of factors need to be weighed, but thinks that age should not be a determining factor.
   “I think there are scales of different offenses that need to be treated differently,” she said. “Everyone makes mistakes, but I think anyone can turn away from temptation no matter how old they are.”
1 Comment
Robert Maronic
8/3/2016 10:39:39 am

Re: "Headmaster Dr. Christian J. Proctor is a huge proponent of trusting students to follow the Honor Code. In fact, he thinks that the school should get to the point where students don’t need any supervision for exams. “We should be able to send the exams home with students,” he said “and have them take the exams on their own time like Washington & Lee students do for their exams.”

I think that North Cross has a good honor code, and should be commended for having students on the Honor Council. However, Headmaster Proctor is being somewhat naive. Exams, tests and quizzes should ALWAYS be supervised or proctored, no pun intended, by a teacher.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Staff Editors:

    Archives

    May 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    September 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    March 2020
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

the Willis Hall Herald

Contact: willishallherald@northcross.org 
4254 Colonial Ave.
Roanoke, VA 240189
(540) 789-7289

Letters to the Editor: willishallherald@northcross.org 

Founded in 2010, and based in the Journalism elective, The Willis Hall Herald is the official student-led publication of the Upper School at North Cross School in Roanoke, VA. The Herald may be published in magazine form three times per year. GeoPrism: The Global Studies Journal may be published in magazine form once or twice per year. The Herald welcomes letters, commentary and submissions of original content that adhere to the Herald's dedication to factual journalism. Letters and other content must be signed and may be edited for length and Herald style. The Herald does not guarantee publication of outside submissions. Please contact Robert Robillard for ads. The Herald won Gold Medals from Columbia Scholastic Press Association in 2012 and 2015. 

The Staff

Editor-in-Chief ........................................................................................................................ Massoki Maka
Managing Editor....................................................................................................................... Eason Zhou
Social Media Editor.................................................................................................................... Eason Zhou
Website Editors...........................................................................................................................Eason Zhou
Opinion Editor.........................................................................................................................Massoki Maka
Graphics Editor................................................................................................................................... Dat Bui
Business Manager.......................................................................................................................Brock Miles
Features Editor......................................................................................................................................Nhi Le
Photography Editor.................................................................................................................. Eason Zhou
Arts Editor...................................................................................................................................Rabia Ferron
Arts and Entertainment Editor.......................................................................................Aadeetri Pandey
Sports Editor............................................................................................................................ Tristan Lange
Staff writers...................................... Rowan Anderson, Anne Bradley Cullen, Didi Dibetle, Lam Do, Antonio Mack, Aadeetri Pandey, Jiale Qin, Veronica Weston.
Graphic Artist .....................................................................................................................Gracean Ratliff
Op-Ed Columnists................................................................................................................... Helen Hertz

Advisor................................................................................................................................ Robert Robillard
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • News
    • Head of School Armistead Lemon
  • Sports 2022-23
  • Features
    • Profiles >
      • Student Profiles
      • New Teacher Profiles
      • Leadership Profiles
      • Seniors: Class of 2021
      • Seniors: Class of 2022
  • GEOPRISM
  • Opinion
  • Arts
    • Scary Stories
    • April Fools Day
  • Print Issues
  • Photos
    • Homecoming
  • Ads
  • Staff
    • Aadeetri Pandey '26
    • Anne Bradley Cullen '26
    • Antonio Mack '26
    • Brock Miles '24
    • Dat Bui '23
    • Didi Dibetle '24
    • Eason Zhou '24
    • Gracean Ratliff '23
    • Hania Raza '24
    • Helen Hertz '24
    • Jiale Qin '26
    • Kenzie Raub '24
    • Lam Do '26
    • Massoki Maka '23
    • Nhi Le '25
    • Rabia Ferron '26
    • Rowan Anderson '26
    • Tristan Lange '26
    • Veronica Weston '26
    • Robert Robillard
  • Resources
  • News Archive
    • Coronavirus
    • Student Profiles
    • Teacher Profiles
    • Sports 2021-22 >
      • Football: State Champs