WILLIS HALL HERALD ONLINE
  • Home
  • News
    • Head of School Armistead Lemon
  • Sports 2022-23
  • Features
    • Profiles >
      • Student Profiles
      • New Teacher Profiles
      • Leadership Profiles
      • Seniors: Class of 2021
      • Seniors: Class of 2022
  • GEOPRISM
  • Opinion
  • Arts
    • Scary Stories
    • April Fools Day
  • Print Issues
  • Photos
    • Homecoming
  • Ads
  • Staff
    • Aadeetri Pandey '26
    • Anne Bradley Cullen '26
    • Antonio Mack '26
    • Brock Miles '24
    • Dat Bui '23
    • Didi Dibetle '24
    • Eason Zhou '24
    • Gracean Ratliff '23
    • Hania Raza '24
    • Helen Hertz '24
    • Jiale Qin '26
    • Kenzie Raub '24
    • Lam Do '26
    • Massoki Maka '23
    • Nhi Le '25
    • Rabia Ferron '26
    • Rowan Anderson '26
    • Tristan Lange '26
    • Veronica Weston '26
    • Robert Robillard
  • Resources
  • News Archive
    • Coronavirus
    • Student Profiles
    • Teacher Profiles
    • Sports 2021-22 >
      • Football: State Champs

 WHH Opinions


The Willis Hall Herald welcomes your opinions on any matter concerning the upper school and its students.
​Please send to willishallherald@northcross.org.

New CDC guidelines: medical or economically motivated?

1/24/2022

0 Comments

 

By Helen Hertz '24

As we near our second year anniversary of COVID-19 in the U.S., somehow, the general thoughts of our government seem to be the same; “How can we continuously value the economy over our citizens?”

While this question almost sounds sarcastic, it is unfortunately a serious question.     The most recent occurrence was December 27, 2021, when the CDC (Centers of Disease Control and Prevention) cut isolation time for contracting COVID-19 in half.  This update was still released even after the discovery of a new COVID variant, omicron. While omicron is thought to be a tamer and less worrying variant to contract, this is not necessarily the case. According to World Health Organization’s director-general, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, "While omicron does appear to be less severe compared to delta, especially in those vaccinated,” said Ghebreyesus, this “does not mean it should be categorized as 'mild’.” 

The idea that a variant of a deadly virus is not that big of a deal, does nothing to assure the safety of the elderly and immune-compromised. Two groups of people whose immune systems would have a challenging time fighting against any sicknesses.

The CDC’s new guideline of five-day quarantine, has some even more interesting rules to follow afterwards. After your five-day quarantine is up, you are free to go as you please, as long as you are not showing severe symptoms. “What are severe symptoms?”, you might ask? Severe symptoms include only a fever. Your fever must be gone for 24 hours before you return to your normal life.

The last guideline is to wear a mask around others for five days after your quarantine ends.  This applies regardless of vaccination status. The unvaccinated, even though they have a higher positive test rate, are bound to the same guidelines as the vaccinated. The most alarming part of these guidelines are that no negative test is required to return to the outside world. If that seems crazy, it’s because it is. 

A negative test is everything. According to an article in the Houston Methodist: Leading Medicine, supported by Dr. Joshua Septimus, the medical director, says a person with COVID can be contagious for 10 days afterwards. Which is what the original quarantine period was, if you are following along. 

The alarming part of this situation is that for an additional five days, someone’s parent, sibling, grandparent, or friend could contract the virus. The very same virus that has killed roughly 854,000 and infected 61.4 million in the U.S. alone. I’m no scientist, which is probably clear in my simplistic explanation of guidelines and safety codes, but I do know enough to realize the CDC cares increasingly more about one thing: the economy.

CDC director, Dr. Rochelle Walensky, said that not only was the quarantine shortened due to scientific evidence, but also to “keep the critical functions of society open and operating.” She is referring to the national shortage of workers in retail jobs and hospitals. Which sounds counterintuitive, because more sickness = even less workers to do their “critical function” for society.  Workers are not disposable, and they cannot be expected to battle off a sickness that attacks even those in the best health. Especially when many of the workers in “essential” jobs interact with those with compromised immune systems and the elderly. So the CDC’s question is answered. The way you continue to value the economy over human lives is by simply pretending that COVID is disappearing. When in reality, it is spiking. 

My specific encounter with COVID is about as maddening as it gets.  Last week, my mother tested positive. She wears her mask in every space necessary, covering all the right places, and has never put herself in the position to be exposed. However, my mother is an educator, and it was quite frankly bound to happen eventually. 

She has continued to test positive, ever since last Thursday. However, since her five days are technically up, and she is not symptomatic (aka no fever), her school required her to return to work. If she does not return to work, she will no longer be paid. However, if she does return, she runs the risk of infecting someone else. 

My mother has to return to work. She cannot afford to stay at home. Especially being the only adult in the house with a day-to-day job. She is responsible for a mortgage, multiple cars, four children, and every single bill that comes her way. If there was a 10 day period of quarantine, which has not yet passed, she could very well be negative, and not have to worry about infecting a student or co-teacher.  The argument that some would make is that she could still test positive for up to 90 days. But to me it isn't the positive test that worries me. It’s the fact that she could still spread the virus, following Dr. Septimus’ claim.     

This is just one example of thousands, but my personal experience with the CDC’s new guidelines have further enlightened me to the fact that the CDC simply does not care about people like my mom.  The CDC is still a part of the government, and just as driven to economic success as the other government agencies. If teachers like my mom don’t go back to work as soon as possible, they are just another statistic on a page of understaffed places of work. 

My mother is not a statistic to me. She is my source of food, housing, and joy. It is extraordinarily difficult for a teacher like her, to not be able to care for her own sickness, and also worry about the lives of her students whom she values. 

I leave you with this - the CDC, whether you support their new guidelines or not, do not model the realistic life of a real American worker. There is no way a successful economy can rise, if these guidelines continue to simply ignore the severity of COVID, and treat it as if it is a fading problem. 

Our second year of COVID may not be our last. Treat guidelines with as much carefulness as possible, and think about the potential person you could be infecting when you step out of quarantine too early.

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Letters to the Editor

    Editors:


    Helen Hertz '24

    Archives

    March 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

the Willis Hall Herald

Contact: willishallherald@northcross.org 
4254 Colonial Ave.
Roanoke, VA 240189
(540) 789-7289

Letters to the Editor: willishallherald@northcross.org 

Founded in 2010, and based in the Journalism elective, The Willis Hall Herald is the official student-led publication of the Upper School at North Cross School in Roanoke, VA. The Herald may be published in magazine form three times per year. GeoPrism: The Global Studies Journal may be published in magazine form once or twice per year. The Herald welcomes letters, commentary and submissions of original content that adhere to the Herald's dedication to factual journalism. Letters and other content must be signed and may be edited for length and Herald style. The Herald does not guarantee publication of outside submissions. Please contact Robert Robillard for ads. The Herald won Gold Medals from Columbia Scholastic Press Association in 2012 and 2015. 

The Staff

Editor-in-Chief ........................................................................................................................ Massoki Maka
Managing Editor....................................................................................................................... Eason Zhou
Social Media Editor.................................................................................................................... Eason Zhou
Website Editors...........................................................................................................................Eason Zhou
Opinion Editor.........................................................................................................................Massoki Maka
Graphics Editor................................................................................................................................... Dat Bui
Business Manager.......................................................................................................................Brock Miles
Features Editor......................................................................................................................................Nhi Le
Photography Editor.................................................................................................................. Eason Zhou
Arts Editor...................................................................................................................................Rabia Ferron
Arts and Entertainment Editor.......................................................................................Aadeetri Pandey
Sports Editor............................................................................................................................ Tristan Lange
Staff writers...................................... Rowan Anderson, Anne Bradley Cullen, Didi Dibetle, Lam Do, Antonio Mack, Aadeetri Pandey, Jiale Qin, Veronica Weston.
Graphic Artist .....................................................................................................................Gracean Ratliff
Op-Ed Columnists................................................................................................................... Helen Hertz

Advisor................................................................................................................................ Robert Robillard
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • News
    • Head of School Armistead Lemon
  • Sports 2022-23
  • Features
    • Profiles >
      • Student Profiles
      • New Teacher Profiles
      • Leadership Profiles
      • Seniors: Class of 2021
      • Seniors: Class of 2022
  • GEOPRISM
  • Opinion
  • Arts
    • Scary Stories
    • April Fools Day
  • Print Issues
  • Photos
    • Homecoming
  • Ads
  • Staff
    • Aadeetri Pandey '26
    • Anne Bradley Cullen '26
    • Antonio Mack '26
    • Brock Miles '24
    • Dat Bui '23
    • Didi Dibetle '24
    • Eason Zhou '24
    • Gracean Ratliff '23
    • Hania Raza '24
    • Helen Hertz '24
    • Jiale Qin '26
    • Kenzie Raub '24
    • Lam Do '26
    • Massoki Maka '23
    • Nhi Le '25
    • Rabia Ferron '26
    • Rowan Anderson '26
    • Tristan Lange '26
    • Veronica Weston '26
    • Robert Robillard
  • Resources
  • News Archive
    • Coronavirus
    • Student Profiles
    • Teacher Profiles
    • Sports 2021-22 >
      • Football: State Champs